Crowdresearch:WinterMilestone 3 Alipta - Darkhorse idea
IDEA 1 - Remove Reputation system - Provide equal Opportunity
Again bringing back the Indian context where we Indians live under social constraints, the average life of an Indian follows a linear path Rohit is working as an Account manager in a commercial Bank, he has spend 9 years of his career checking balance sheets, Profit & loss statements, he comes to office at 9AM and leave by 7 PM, he hate this job because his interest lies somewhere else, he likes photography and wanted to be a wild life photographer. Rohit could not earn any reputation as a worker as he feels this job is stereotype and anybody can do this. He could have earned a reputation if he had been allowed to purse photography as a career path
Especially in context to India we have seen that a average rated worker keeps doing the same type of job through his life, this brings dis satisfaction, de-motivations, and ultimately low productivity and finally retrenchment.
Reputation system in traditional communities is relatively inefficient and relies on physical communication e.g. through word-of-mouth
Attempts to misrepresent reliability and to manipulate reputation are common in traditional communities.
24% of India’s population is completely illiterate. Another 30% is barely literate. Many users in developing countries are still new to ICTs ( information and communication technologies)
A worker calculating 2+2= and earning a handful after working 100 HITs may be getting a high rating but he may be losing an opportunity to showcase his talent in other field where he/she can excel, because he is happy with his earnings and may be
The result of 2 + 2 is always 4 and judging worker who has little maths knowledge How does a requester judge the quality of this task
What is expected from Workers? 1. Go to http://www.clkmg.com/sah7/filipeneil100 2. Enter your email address 3. Click "Sign up" 4. Then the page will again ask you to enter your email address and then Sign up
5. Check your email for confirmation Required proof that task was finished? 1. Email address(es you used to Sign up 2. Paste the URLs you were redirected to after successful submission here
3. Paste the confirmation email you received
If hundred workers take up this task the result will be same, but based on what the rating is provided
Quality- ruled out Time taken - ruled out is it just the job is done- then these 100 workers will have the same rating lets say +
But in actual are these workers are capable of doing some other task which are complex/ and require some amount of thought process or analytical bent of mind, lets say a complex maths calculation, or designing a logo, or writing an article, commenting on a post the
For Certain task what criteria is followed in establishing a rating
- Filling up a survey form
- Signup in the site
Consider an example - in India reputation comes with experience, consider a real-life example, in a school there are multiple teachers teaching different subjects, but
Consider a govt organisation, where the
A low rated worker may leave the system & re-enter the community with a different identity.
Boomerang is trying to establish a relationship between a worker & requester using the following equation
- Low rated W = Low rated R
- Medium rated W = Medium rated R
- High rated W = High rated R
To set the context let's take an example, there are 10 workers and all the 10 workers are equally performing good, now for a particular task, if we disclose that the output of worker A is selected then for the next set of task the requester will prefer getting it done by worker A, where as in reality worker B is equally good as A and others. Similarly, let's say a requester had posted a task of designing a logo 100+ workers came up with different concept but the requester pick up one, but he is not making a public announcement that which logo he has picked up.
The above process in a way will provide equal opportunity to all workers & requester.
- Remove the concept of reputation system and have a neutral platform where workers come and work based on their choice. This reduces the human tendency to only look for task from requester having high ratings, not everyone can have a high rating, the question what come here is what will happen to such tasks coming from requester's having a low rating while the task being interesting, in a similar way a requester would always look for a reputed worker what will happen to other workers having low rating. Everybody wants a good boss, but if we don't get we don't quit jobs, we live with it get adjusted to it.
IDEA 2 - Offering Certificate courses & full time programs on Crowd sourcing
Our Industry runs on stamps, students passing outs from premier institutions always enjoy the extra privilege in the workplace, society, family gathering. They are always being considered to solve complex issues & bigger problems which in turn bring reputation to them from social circle, publication & media houses, Industries and educational institutes
Top Performers like first class graduates from premier institutes are always preferred as fresher in an organization. Keeping this picture in mind we introduce programs certificate courses ran by Industry experts in universities for a Crowd worker
In UX domain we have consultants coming in from different fields, Psychology, social scientist, UX designers, visual designer, but only few can reach to their dream companies, and those few are the ones who have earned degrees from Premier institutes.
Crowd Worker can get a stamp and earn reputation just by the virtue of the certificate he/she holds. He/She can name himself as a XXX certified Crowd Worker
IDEA 3 - Offering a variable pay with a quarterly payout